Skip to main content
PEERS Home
Promoting mental health, empowerment, and social inclusion.
  • Home
  • Programs
  • Calendar
  • News
  • PEERS TV
  • PEERS Radio
  • Blog
  • About

News /Growing number of consumers living below poverty line

5 comments
Presenters Donita Diamata, right, and Amy Zulich

People with mental health issues make up 36 percent of Social Security allocations — up from 24 percent two decades prior — and possess a standard of living that often falls below federal poverty guidelines, according to Alternatives presenters Donita Diamata and Amy Zulich.

With the federal poverty guideline set at $10,890 per year and Social Security payments set at $8,064 annually, consumers relying solely on government income face a deficit of more than $2,000 each year in meeting basic living expenses, according to Diamata.

In addition to not being able to afford the basics of food, medical care, and shelter, consumers find that their mental health conditions worsen with the stress brought about by poverty, Diamata said.

"The stress of poverty can worsen symptoms and impair basic functioning," Diamata said. "Mental health consumers are also more likely to engage in behaviors that risk physical health when in upsetting situations. These behaviors are not necessarily undertaken with harmful intent, but may be used as coping behaviors to provide comfort or relief from a situation perceived as inescapable."

Despite the fact that many people with mental health issues can and want to work and rise above Social Security, Zulich says it's not that simple.

Seventy percent of employers say they are reluctant to hire someone with a past psychiatric history, making it extremely difficult to break the cycle of poverty among people with mental health issues, according to Zulich.

If a consumer is hired somewhere, Zulich said, it is likely the job pays minimum wage and has minimal benefits, if any at all, which makes real and sustained recovery very difficult to achieve.

"The gap between Medicaid/Medicare income levels and private insurance is a real problem," Zulich said. "If you are hospitalized and don’t have insurance, you end up with a giant bill."

Housing is another widespread obstacle for consumers to overcome in achieving wellness, according to Diamata. In fact, she says it’s so common that the image of mental illness and homelessness often go hand-in-hand.

"When you search for images on poverty, homelessness, and mental illness, you start seeing many of the same pictures popping up,” Diamata said. “It’s depressing. Those things shouldn’t go together."

While those in need may turn to low-income housing, arrangements are anything but guaranteed, according to Diamata. Such housing is in short supply throughout the country and long waiting lists are common; California waiting lists are a minimum of one year to a high of 6-8 years.

For those trying their chances at renting, the stats are even bleaker. In 2010, a person receiving SSI needed to pay 112 percent of their monthly income for a 1-bedroom apartment and 99 percent for a studio or efficiency apartment, according to Diamata.

Conversely, Federal Housing Affordability guidelines state that low-income households should pay no more than 30 percent of monthly income, or $211 per month for SSI recipients, towards housing costs.

According to Zulich, numbers like these underscore the urgency and need to close the income gap, but multiple factors continue to prevent that from happening.

A widespread fear of losing benefits, lack of employment education resources, messages from society about never being able to work, increasing economic disparities, and the current economic crisis discourage many consumers from re-entering the workforce, Zulich said.

"Consumers are often strongly discouraged to regain control over their own money and are given little support to be successful with finances," Zulich said. "Prescription medications can make it difficult to think clearly and keep up on personal finances. In addition, many are told they will never be able to work, and maintaining disability benefits should be their goal."

It's a vicious cycle, Zulich says.

"It's impossible to be well if your basic needs aren’t met," Zulich said. "If you don't have access to food, medical care, safe housing, how do you build the rest of your recovery?"
 

Comments

Submitted by Randy Bosin (not verified) on November 4, 2011 - 3:45pm.

This is so important and I'm so glad they had this workshop at Alternatives - it truly is, as they said, the elephant in the room. The reality is that most consumers who rely on SSI or SSDI for most of their income can expect to become progressively poorer year after year because the way the annual Social Security COLA is calculated sysematically UNDERESTIMATES the actual increase in the cost of living for most people on these programs (or on regular Social Security). Yet we are not talking about this, nor is there much effort to address this very serious dynamic.

Please, let's make this a much bigger focus of our work and for Alternatives 2012!

  • reply
Submitted by Jen padron (not verified) on November 5, 2011 - 4:03am.

We must work to develop the infrastructure of our peer workforce to insure a livable wage. I really believe in this.

  • reply
Submitted by Shannon on November 7, 2011 - 6:57pm.

Hi Randy,

Thanks for your comment. I completely agree. When you break down the numbers of what it takes to live nowadays, especially in metropolitan areas, it's both sad and comical. $211/month for housing? In San Francisco, you can't even rent a parking space for $211/month let alone a place to live. It's all very sobering and just getting worse in this economy. I really look forward to continuing the dialogue next year and brainstorming solutions throughout the next decade.

Cheers,
Shannon

  • reply
Submitted by Shannon on November 7, 2011 - 6:59pm.

Jen, you are absolutely correct!

  • reply
Submitted by Aggy (not verified) on December 25, 2011 - 1:54pm.

If only there were more celevr people like you!

  • reply

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
Please verify that you're a human visitor, to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Top News Tags

  • Empowerment
  • Alternatives
  • Orlando
  • 2011
  • Florida
  • Media
  • spirituality
  • WRAP
  • SAMHSA
  • PEERS

News Archives

  • May, 2013
  • April, 2013
  • February, 2013
  • January, 2013
  • October, 2012
  • September, 2012
  • August, 2012
  • July, 2012
  • June, 2012
  • May, 2012
  • April, 2012
  • March, 2012
  • January, 2012
  • December, 2011
  • November, 2011
  • October, 2011
  • September, 2011
  • August, 2011
  • May, 2011
  • April, 2011
  • March, 2011
  • February, 2011
  • December, 2010
  • October, 2010

Calendar

  • May 21, 2013 - 10:00am - 12:00pm
    Black Men Speak
  • May 21, 2013 - 12:00pm - 1:00pm
    Mindfulness Movement Series (NEW)
  • May 22, 2013 - 8:30am - 5:00pm
    WRAP Three Day Orientation
  • May 22, 2013 - 10:00am - 12:00pm
    African-American Action Team

View more Events

Read Archived PEERS Newsletters

PEERS helped in the recovery of nearly 1000 people last year. Help us reach even more. Donate.

Sign up for our Newsletter

Follow us on

Facebook Twitter

Funding Provided By:

Alameda County Behavioral Health Care Services Mental Health Services Act

Peers Envisioning and Engaging in Recovery Services (PEERS) is a non-profit organization.
333 Hegenberger Road, Oakland CA 94621 | Phone (510) 832 7337 | Contact Us
© 2013 PEERS, All rights reserved

Sign in